38 C
New Delhi
Thursday 28 May 2020

Uttar Pradesh posters: Singhvi asks if minor rapists should be named too

Defending the Uttar Pradesh government's action, S-G Tushar Mehta said one couldn't wield a gun in the public and then demand privacy

Editorials

Reforms By Modi Run Into Tired Socialist Criticism

The motley group of right-thinking Indians in this socialist society should not only promote the reforms announced last week but also push every Indian government and political party towards better economics

In India

अदिति सिंह ने ट्विटर से हटाया पार्टी का नाम

प्रवासी मजदूरों की बस द्वारा अवाजाही के प्रकरण मामले में रायबरेली सदर की विधायक अदिति सिंह ने आईएनसी पर सवाल उठाए थे

जम्मू-कश्मीर में पुलवामा जैसा आतंकी हमला दोहराने की साजिश नाकाम

जम्मू-कश्मीर पुलिस और सुरक्षा बलों ने बम डिस्पोज़ल यूनिट को बुलाने से पहले आस-पास के पूरे इलाके को लोगों को वहां से हटा दिया था

The Supreme Court today refused to relieve the Uttar Pradesh government in the case of posters plastered across the city of Lucknow as notice to the rioters to compensate for the properties they have damaged or face confiscation of their own properties. The Allahabad High Court had, the day before yesterday, ordered their removal. The Yogi government had challenged the high court order in the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court has, however, referred the matter to a larger bench.

The vacation bench of Justice Umesh Uday Lalit and Justice Anirudh Bose referred the matter to a larger bench. Justice Lalit said that the Chief Justice (SA Bobde) would look into the matter.

The apex court also allowed all persons, whose names are in the hoardings, to present their case before the highest court of the country.

S-G’s arguments in Supreme Court

Earlier, Solicitor-General Tushar Mehta said in the court that 95 people had initially been identified and their pictures were put on hoardings. There is evidence against 57 of these people, but the accused have now challenged the displays of their names and photos in public places in the high court, citing their right to privacy, he said and added, “but the 1994 decision of the Supreme Court in the Puttaswamy case had dealt with other aspects of the right to privacy”.

“There is an assumption that you have waived your right of privacy by appearing in public,” Mehta said. “You are in a public domain here. If you wield your gun in a riot, you cannot claim privacy.”

The S-G referred to a verdict of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom that had said such posters were “not only a measure to act as a deterrent” but also to recover “liabilities” from the rioters.

To this, Justice Lalit said if people of a particular organisation appeared in front of riots or destruction of public property, the government’s action against them would be a separate issue, but what is the logic behind putting a picture of ordinary citizens? The solicitor-general said the Uttar Pradesh government put up these hoardings — and communicated the same to the media — only after warning the rioters and seeking information from them.

People may not be restrained, government still bound by law: SC

Justice Anirudh Bose said that this was the difference between the people and the government. Many times, people break the law and do something, but the government is restrained to run and work according to the law.

Justice Lalit said that at the moment there was no law supporting the action of the Uttar Pradesh government. “If there is a law, tell me,” the judge exclaimed.

Mehta said that the Supreme Court of Britain had provided that if an issue or action was directly related to the public or comes in the public record, privacy no longer mattered. Removing the hoarding is not a big deal, the S-G said, but the issue is larger. Any person can do anything in private life but all of that cannot be approved in public.

The S-G said, “After issuing notices to the accused, we made a final decision when we did not get any response. We must recover damages from these 57 people. We gave a 30-day extension for the payment.”

Singhvi defends Darapuri

Abhishek Manu Singhvi of the Indian National Congress (INC) today raised the issue of former IPS officer SR Darapuri, after citing Solicitor General Tushar Mehta’s order to justify the British Royal Supreme Court’s operation exposé in law. Singhvi said that the UP government had ignored some basic rules. “Take the case of a child rapist and a murder accused. Since when do we have in this country a policy to name and shame them? If there is such a policy, a man walking in the streets is liable to be lynched…” he said.

“I can imagine if a private person does this [puts up posters],” Singhvi said. “ But I don’t think we have anarchy yet that a state is doing this.”

Singhvi said that despite the passage of three years after the Supreme Court order on black money, the government had not yet made public the bank defaulters’ names. “This is pick-and-choose,” Singhvi remarked, adding that the UP government had issued a government order and notified it. “Where is the final order of the authority? This is a mega-blanket approach to name and shame me!”

Subscribe to our newsletter

To be updated with all the latest news, offers and special announcements.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

- Advertisement -

Articles

Tirupati: Where Protector Of Three Worlds Needs Protection

Tirupati temple authorities were considering the liquidation of land-assets and buildings donated by devotees to Lord Venkateswara to help tide over what the management called “COVID-19 related financial crisis” and an inability to pay staff salaries

আম্ফানের আঘাতে চূর্ণ মমতার আস্ফালন

গ্রামবাঙ্গালার বিস্তৃত অংশে শাসক দলের স্থানীয় আধিকারিকদের এতটাই প্রভাব এবং ক্ষমতা যে DBT সত্ত্বেও ভীতিপ্রদর্শন করে নিজেদের কাটমানি বা অংশটুকু তারা ক্ষেত্রবিশেষে আদায় করতে পারে

Paatal Lok: Antidote To Anti-Hindu Propaganda

A Family Man that upholds the Pakistani PoV on Kashmir or the ilk of Leila and Paatal Lok that defames Hinduism cannot be made if nationalist subscribers react wisely

News

अदिति सिंह ने ट्विटर से हटाया पार्टी का नाम

प्रवासी मजदूरों की बस द्वारा अवाजाही के प्रकरण मामले में रायबरेली सदर की विधायक अदिति सिंह ने आईएनसी पर सवाल उठाए थे

जम्मू-कश्मीर में पुलवामा जैसा आतंकी हमला दोहराने की साजिश नाकाम

जम्मू-कश्मीर पुलिस और सुरक्षा बलों ने बम डिस्पोज़ल यूनिट को बुलाने से पहले आस-पास के पूरे इलाके को लोगों को वहां से हटा दिया था

Nepal, after blowing hot, wishes to de-escalate

The Government of Nepal, removing the proceedings of the constitutional amendment from the agenda of the parliament scheduled for 27 May, now says it is looking for a national consensus on the new map

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: