14.9 C
New Delhi
Monday 16 December 2019
India Trump idea on regulating Google 'unfathomable'

Trump idea on regulating Google ‘unfathomable’

Trump on Tuesday issued an unspecified warning to tech firms, presumably related to his claims that they suppress conservative views

Washington: His attacks on Google drew headlines, but President Donald Trump would face an impossible task if his administration tried to regulate the leading internet search engine and its news results.

Legal and media experts say Google and other internet firms enjoy the same constitutional protections on free speech as news outlets, precluding any government interference with the search results that displease the president.

“Each search engine’s editorial judgment is much like many other familiar editorial judgments,” said Eugene Volokh, a University of California-Los Angeles law professor and author of a 2012 white paper on the constitutional First Amendment protection of search engines.

Volokh said in a blog post on Reason.com after Trump’s remarks that algorithms developed by Google and others are “editorial judgments about what users are likely to find interesting and valuable.

And all these exercises of editorial judgment are fully protected by the First Amendment.” Eric Goldman, co-director of the High-Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University, said there is ample legal precedent for Google’s free-speech rights.

“Search engines fully qualify for First Amendment protections for their search results. Numerous cases going back over 15 years have confirmed this,” Goldman said.

“Any effort by Trump to ‘fix’ search engine results will violate the First Amendment. It’s not even a close question.”

Trump’s comments however stoked debate on the question when he assailed Google for what he termed “rigged” results that hide news from conservative outlets and promote content from what he called “left-wing” media.

Google countered the remarks by saying that “search is not used to set a political agenda and we don’t bias our results toward any political ideology.”

The president’s comments follow criticism from Republican lawmakers including House majority leader Kevin McCarthy who claimed that “conservatives are too often finding their voices silenced” on online platforms.

Trump on Tuesday issued an unspecified warning to tech firms, presumably related to his claims that they suppress conservative views. He repeated his claim yesterday, saying big tech firms “treat conservatives and Republicans very unfairly,” but stopped short of calling for regulation.

“You know what we want? Not regulation, we want fairness,” he told reporters.

Yesterday, Trump posted on Twitter what was purported to be a series of screen grabs that showed Google’s home page promoted State of the Union addresses by former president Barack Obama but stopped when he took office, using the hashtag #StopTheBias.

There is little evidence to show algorithms by online firms are based on politics, and many conservatives including Trump himself have large a social media following.

Analysts say it would be dangerous to try to regulate how search engines work to please a government or political faction.

“Google is a private company with its own algorithms and the government has absolutely no control in how it conducts business,” said Ken Paulson, former USA Today editor who heads the Newseum’s First Amendment Center and is dean of

communications at Middle Tennessee State University.

“The broader threat to First Amendment freedoms comes when the most powerful man in the world repeatedly says that you can only trust him, not news organisations or the search engines that deliver their coverage.”

But even without constitutional protection, the idea of regulating billions of Google searches would be an impossible task.

“We deliberately don’t regulate every interaction in the economy because we know it’s unfathomable,” said David Balto, a former Federal Trade Commission and Justice Department enforcement lawyer.

Balto maintained that Trump’s suggestion “is an Orwellian concept that might fit well in ‘1984’ but is totally inconsistent with our tenets of democracy.” Other analysts say the Trump comments are merely an attempt to rally his base and raise doubts about news organizations investigating him.

“Authoritarian regimes would love to have that power over search engines,” said Ed Black, president and CEO of the Computer and Communications Industry Association, a trade group that includes Google and Facebook.

“The US government should be an advocate against this type of censorship.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi

Leave a Reply

Opinion

Justice That Is Instant Is Travesty

But neither the state nor society can wash their hands off this social craving for settling scores in the name of doing justice to the victim

Karnataka Voters Punished INC, JDS Leaders

Even the BJP was not confident of the result even as their leaders kept saying for public consumption they were winning all the 15 seats

The United States Of The World

The United States, stereotyped as the land of plenty and plentiful guns, is still a destination of choice for people from across the world

प्याज़ के आँसू न रोएँ — महंगाई से किसान, उपभोक्ता दोनों को फ़ायदा

जिस अल्प मुद्रास्फीति की वजह से वे सरकार से बहुत खुश थे, उसी 1.38 प्रतिशत की खाद्यान्न मुद्रास्फीति के कारण किसानों को अपने पैदावार के लिए समुचित मूल्य नहीं मिल रहे थे

CAB Can Correct Wrongs Of NRC

… if the government can fix the inept bureaucracy and explain what happens to those marked as aliens, as the neighbours are not taking them back
- Advertisement -

Elsewhere

NEFT transaction 24×7 beginning 16 December

NEFT is a method of online transaction, in which you can transfer to another bank account up to Rs 2 lakh online at a time

Decision to amend Citizenship Act 1,000% honest: PM Modi

'We have brought this law to give citizenship to minorities of Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh who have endured a lot of persecution'

Nirbhaya case convicts: Why 2 will take longer to die

Further, a source in the jail said while four rapists and killers of Nirbhaya are supposed to hang on one day, they have ordered 10 ropes

India to begin ODI series as favourites against West Indies

Shimron Hetmyer and Nicholas Pooran have shown their ability in T20; if the WI must challenge India, they will have to do the same in ODIs

‘Rahul Savarkar’ remark riles INC ally Shiv Sena

More newsworthy than the BJP's response that Rahul cannot even dream of being a Savarkar is the protest by Shiv Sena, INC's ally in Maharashtra

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: