18.9 C
New Delhi
Sunday 15 December 2019
Economy Business Ta-ta, Mistry!

Ta-ta, Mistry!

[dropcap]T[/dropcap]he news media has been agog with news of the ‘sudden’ termination of Cyrus Pallonji Mistry’s services as the chairman of the Tata group of companies, with the right wing in the country coming down like a tonne of bricks on Ratan Naval Tata on social media, led by BJP’s Rajya Sabha MP Subramanian Swamy habitually hitting him below the belt with a comment सिर्फ़ News wouldn’t reproduce. The allegation made by Mistry in his parting letter that the tycoon from the family has bent some rules for mergers, acquisitions and other deals may not be all wrong, but it misses the point of character that Tata is known for among all Indian industries and arguably those of the world. From philanthropy to activities under corporate social responsibility to impressionism, the Tatas have made a mark in society not for being money-spinners but for standing for values the group held close to its heart. To chase profits, a worker could seek out any other business house. It was Mistry’s problem that he had presumed that this tacit but well-known rule would be bent to suit the holder of 18% shares of the company that his Shapoorji Pallonji & Company held in the Tata group. In fact, prestige is so important for Ratan Tata that he is contemplating buying out all these shares even if that means a humongous financial burden of $10 billion — if only to ensure that the irksome, deposed chairman shuts up! The crux of the matter, however, is not that it is philistine to talk ill of a company after leaving it.

True, Ratan Tata is a pale shadow of the illustrious JRD (Jehangir Ratanji Dadabhoy) Tata who neither got embroiled in controversies like the Radia Tapes nor made costly decisions comparable to the acquisition of Jaguar-Land Rover; nor did JRD fail to gauge the politics of a land selected for an upcoming factory like the Nano factory Ratan chose to build in West Bengal and failed. But JRD worked in a largely socialist India where the mixed economy meant a favourable disposition of all political parties for a motley group of industrialists including the Tatas and high entry barriers for first-generation entrepreneurs. Ratan, in contrast, operated in a competitive India that had arrived on the international scene with a big bang in the 1990s. Competition can make a businessman desperate; it can also push him to wrong decisions besides surrounding him with rivals baying for his blood. Somewhere Ratan had to make a point to Bill Ford; on another occasion, he had to justify the Tatas’ concern for the have-nots. So, he bought a luxury car brand to underscore India’s arrival on the world scene, much as it threatened to spread his resources thin. And he had to build a car priced slightly above the cost of a 150 cc motorcycle, although a car being an index of upward mobility wouldn’t appeal to the poor if marketed as a vehicle of the poor. Finally, while no act of corruption can be condoned, his loose talks with corporate communicator Niira Radia did not eventually bring him large chunks of the 2G spectrum. If anything, the recording, when played, made him come across as a grandstander rather than a scheming crony. None of these activities, noticeably, made a Dhirubhai Ambani out of a Ratan Tata. Behaving like a dyed-in-the-wool Tata, he stepped aside when he was in his prime — an unforgettable act without which the world outside business circles would not have known Cyrus Mistry, no matter how rich the non-Tata businessman might have been.

In Indian business, the bottom line is family. The talk of merit is all fine, but after the flamboyant Russi Mody, here is another sharp capitalist who fell short of being a Tata, expected of anybody filling those shoes. Let Mistry revel in what he is good at somewhere else while Ratan Tata excels in being a flagbearer of the Tata ethos, which is beyond the balance sheet. Those who uphold the ideology of individual liberty and free markets must appreciate the fact that the Tatas do not run on taxpayers’ money; they are entitled to choose what gives them maximum satisfaction.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi
Sirf News Editorial Board
Sirf News Editorial Boardhttps://www.sirfnews.com
Voicing the collective stand of Sirf News' (सिर्फ़ News') editors on a given issue


  1. All the years we have spent learning praise of Taras from our parents.. Taras gave India steel, Airlines..how they are different from Ambanis… All in all Taras are name of Values and Ethos for Business in India

Leave a Reply


Justice That Is Instant Is Travesty

But neither the state nor society can wash their hands off this social craving for settling scores in the name of doing justice to the victim

Karnataka Voters Punished INC, JDS Leaders

Even the BJP was not confident of the result even as their leaders kept saying for public consumption they were winning all the 15 seats

The United States Of The World

The United States, stereotyped as the land of plenty and plentiful guns, is still a destination of choice for people from across the world

प्याज़ के आँसू न रोएँ — महंगाई से किसान, उपभोक्ता दोनों को फ़ायदा

जिस अल्प मुद्रास्फीति की वजह से वे सरकार से बहुत खुश थे, उसी 1.38 प्रतिशत की खाद्यान्न मुद्रास्फीति के कारण किसानों को अपने पैदावार के लिए समुचित मूल्य नहीं मिल रहे थे

CAB Can Correct Wrongs Of NRC

… if the government can fix the inept bureaucracy and explain what happens to those marked as aliens, as the neighbours are not taking them back
- Advertisement -


Gurdwara discards 30 kg of cooked dal, realising it was ‘plastic’

The historic Gurudwara Bangla Sahib realised again the next day that the lentils were fake but got alerted before the dal was cooked

Prashant Kishor to campaign for AAP in Delhi election

Prashant Kishor has been successful as an election strategist in most campaigns: BJP at Centre 2014, JDU in Bihar 2015, INC in Punjab 2017

Service sector picks pace; trade deficit reduces

Service exports stood at $ 17.70 billion in October, registering a growth of 5.25%; trade deficit declined from $ 17.58 billion in 2018 to $ 12.12 billion

Sabarimala verdict review: SC snubs Fathima, Bindu

Ignoring the court decision to refer the Sabarimala review pleas to a 7-judge bench, the petitioners tried to get an order to enter the shrine immediately

Andhra Cabinet okays Disha Bill that dictates judiciary

While ordering the prosecution to complete its work in 14 days is permissible, Andhra Pradesh cannot set a time limit for the judiciary

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: