21.5 C
New Delhi
Saturday 4 April 2020

‘Nationalism’ has negative connotations in West, Bhagwat realises

Years after PM Narendra Modi miscommunicated his message to the West via Reuters, sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat blacklists 'nationalism'

Editorials

In India

Years after Manmohan Vaidya tried to impress this upon swayamsevaks of the RSS, sarsanghchalak Mohan Bhagwat said it during a programme in Ranchi. He narrated the incident from the stage during one of his travels to the United Kingdom. Bhagwat told the audience, while he was talking to RRS volunteers in the UK, he came to know that the meanings of words in the conversation varied. “Therefore, do not use this word ‘nationalism’,” he said.

“Saying ‘nation’ will do, ‘national’ is okay, ‘nationality’ is fine too, but don’t utter ‘nationalism’ because nationalism means Hitler, Nazism, Fascism. The senses of these words have changed,” Bhagwat said.

Bhagwat said during his speech, “What do we observe a country doing once it becomes a superpower? It dominates the whole world. All the world’s tools are used for that one nation. Political power over the whole world, be it directly or indirectly… they try to achieve this. We try to paint the world in our own colours. All this goes on and on. So the learned people in a large part of the world think that it is dangerous for a country to grow as a nation.”

Bhagwat went on to explain he was talking to a group of 50 odd intellectuals who interrupted as he spoke. A swayamsevak rose to say, “Be careful about the meanings of words, Bhagwat ji. English is not your language and you will speak according to what you read in the book. But the meaning of words in a conversation varies. Do not use this word ‘nationalism’. You will say ‘nation’, ‘national’, ‘nationality’, but never ‘nationalism’ because Nationalism means Hitler, Nazism, Fascism.” Bhagwat said he was relaying what he heard from that event in Britain.

After he became the country’s prime minister, this word stuck out as a jarring note in an interview of Narendra Modi with Reuters. The news agency had asked him how he reacted to the allegation that he was a “Hindu nationalist”. Prime Minister Modi replied, “I am a Hindu. That is not a problem. I am a nationalist. That is not a problem.” Clearly, what Prime Minister Modi and his interviewer meant by “nationalism” were a world apart.

While Indians by and large use “nationalism” and “patriotism” interchangeably, the second definition of “nationalism” in the Oxford English Dictionary, which is the more popular sense in which it is used in the West is:

(sometimes disapproving) a feeling of loving your country very much and being very proud of it; a feeling that your country is better than any other

Oxford English Dictionary

In Merriam-Webster, which is more popular in the US, the definition of the term that make it synonymous with “national supremacism” figures as the first entry [in standard dictionaries, definitions are arranged in the decreasing order of popularity. The American English dictionary defines “nationalism” as:

especiallya sense of national consciousness (see CONSCIOUSNESS sense 1c) exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups

Merriam-Webster

This was one of the issues with Sangh parlance that Sirf News had raised in 2018.

Coronavirus worldwide update, with focus on India, LIVE

Since the facts and figures related to the novel coronavirus disease 2019 (nCOVID-19, COVID-19 or COVID) are changing by the minute, Sirf News has begun this blog to keep the readers updated with information coming from authentic sources

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

- Advertisement -

Articles

China Is Guilty, But How Will World Retaliate?

The attack has to be calibrated as the world has invested heavily in China and that country, in turn, has markets worldwide, making your own economy vulnerable when you take measures against Beijing

Sewa In COVID Times: Living ‘Service Before Self’ Credo

Sewa International volunteers were first off the starting block, setting up non-medical helplines for the four regional areas — West Coast, East Coast, Midwest, and Southwest — for a coordinated national response, where people can call in for assistance

India And US: Same COVID, Different Prescriptions

The different social structures, experiences in the leaders of the two countries, variation in the degree of political capital, etc make India and the US react differently to the global COVID pandemic

China Is Guilty, But How Will World Retaliate?

The attack has to be calibrated as the world has invested heavily in China and that country, in turn, has markets worldwide, making your own economy vulnerable when you take measures against Beijing

Sewa In COVID Times: Living ‘Service Before Self’ Credo

Sewa International volunteers were first off the starting block, setting up non-medical helplines for the four regional areas — West Coast, East Coast, Midwest, and Southwest — for a coordinated national response, where people can call in for assistance

India And US: Same COVID, Different Prescriptions

The different social structures, experiences in the leaders of the two countries, variation in the degree of political capital, etc make India and the US react differently to the global COVID pandemic

For fearless journalism