27 C
New Delhi
Wednesday 13 November 2019
India Muslim side apologises after questioning ASI findings

Muslim side apologises after questioning ASI findings

Rajeev Dhavan, advocate for the Muslim side, apologised for colleague Meenakshi Arara's act of questioning the ASI report on Wednesday


- Advertisment -

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi

After questioning the ASI report in the Supreme Court in the Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid title dispute case, the Muslim side on Thursday reversed its stand and apologised for expressing doubt over the scientific finding. Rajeev Dhavan, advocate for the Muslim side, apologised for questioning the report of the Archaeological Survey of India before the constitutional bench of five judges hearing the case.

Dhavan said that he did not want to question the authenticity of the ASI report. Dhavan said, “It cannot be expected that every page should be signed.” The authorship of the report and its summary need not be questioned. If we have wasted the time of the bench, we apologise for it.

During the hearing of the case on Wednesday, another lawyer representing the Muslim side, Meenakshi Arora, had said that every chapter of the ASI had a mention of the authors, but its summary did not. Apart from the Chief Justice, Justices SA Bobde, DY Chandrachud, Ashok Bhushan and SK Abdul Nazir said that Dhavan had said at the beginning of the hearing that he could not give up his right to question. The judges said further that he had also said that any piece of evidence could not be dismissed because the court has accepted them.

The bench said further that the Hindu and Muslim sides would have to conclude their arguments within the stipulated time, because not a single day will be given after 18 October. Chief Justice Gogoi said, “After 18 October, there will be no additional time of a single day.”

CJI Gogoi said if the court was expected to deliver the judgment in four weeks, it would be difficult if the hearing were to stretch beyond 18 October. The court asked the Muslim side to wind up their questions on the ASI report in a single day. The court said that there were several days off in October and only one lawyer from the Hindu side would be given a chance to respond.

Significantly, on Wednesday, Meenakshi Arora had said if a structure was destroyed in a dilapidated condition and it was not built, and later another structure was erected on that vacant site, a claim couldn’t be made against the new structure. She was basing her argument on one of the theories on the Ayodhya dispute according to which Mir Baqi, Babar’s general, had found some ruins on the spot before he erected a mosque on it. Since the ASI findings include also some requiem in Arabic, found generally on gravestones, it is assumed that a Muslim graveyard might have come up on the spot before the temple(s) that stood there were abandoned and that, later, the graveyard lay in a state of neglect, too. However, that is a weak ground, as a mosque is not supposed to be built on a graveyard.

Demolition of the structure, Arora had said on Wednesday, was an important contention in the case and that the ASI report did not mention the demolition of the old structure. ASI’s report on this was silent, she claimed. On this, Justice Bobde had said that the ASI report had become a case record and that until the court found some contradiction in the report, it would remain a part of the record. The court reminded Arora that this point was not raised by her in the trial court.

Editor’s note

Arora’s argument is as frivolous as that of Jilani where he had said that the Ramcharitmanas found no mention of the demolition of any Ram temple on the spot. Just as a holy book is not supposed to chronicle news of the times, the brief of the ASI does not include writing commentaries on the process of constructions and demolitions. Archaeology is a science involving aspects of physics, chemistry, geology, palaeontology and evolutionary anthropology to determine periods of existence of relics, which does not involve commentaries on conquests and civic activities of the government of that era.

Leave a Reply


Guru Nanak Jayanti: What First Sikh Guru Taught

While Guru Nanak urged people to 'nām japo, kirat karo, vand chhako', he stood for several values while he also fought various social evils

Muhammed Who Inconvenienced Muslims

Archaeologist KK Muhammed had earlier got on the nerves of the leftist intelligentsia for exposing their nexus with Islamic extremists

UCC Now, Rajnath Hints: Here’s How Modi Can Do It

Modi can argue in a manner to make UCC look secular and pro-Hindu at the same time, making a Muslim or Christian counterargument impossible

Tulasi: Two Stories, One Reason For Devotion

The Padma Purana, Devi Bhagavatam and Skanda Purana tell the story of Tulasi or Vrinda differently but the essence of devotion is a constant

BJP Cannot Afford Ideological Confusion

Being everything to everybody is Congress, which now faces doom. Socialism, secularism and 'sabka vishwas' are pushing BJP down the same path.
- Advertisement -


Guru Nanak Jayanti: What First Sikh Guru Taught

While Guru Nanak urged people to 'nām japo, kirat karo, vand chhako', he stood for several values while he also fought various social evils

Kajal of India reaps ‘reward’ of marrying a Pakistani

The case of Kajal differs from love jihad stories: a country rather than an individual has dashed her hopes, but there is a similarity, too

Congress to help in Maha’ govt formation under 5 conditions

They just begin with not letting a Thackeray be the chief minister, but even otherwise, Congress and NCP leaders are not getting along well

Jharkhand BJP haunted by Maharashtra alliance woes?

A BJP source said that the outcome of Maharashtra affected the party's Jharkhand policy where it refused to give 'winnable' seats away

Industrial production at 8-year low in September

Most industrial groups registered negative growth rates in the period, reminiscent of 2011-12 when manufacturing had gone into a tailspin

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: