7.2 C
New York
Saturday 4 December 2021

Buy now

Ad

HomePoliticsIndiaLG in Delhi has more power than governor of a state: SC

LG in Delhi has more power than governor of a state: SC

|

Delhi: The Supreme Court today said that Delhi’s lieutenant governor has more power than the governor of a state as he does not have to act on the aid and advice of the council of ministers all the time.

It said that the governor of a state has to more or less act on the aid and advice of the government expect in the case of discretion that could be exercised by the office.

The government claimed that the cannot govern Delhi, has no role in the affairs of the national capital. It is only the council of ministers, headed by the chief minister, which can govern, it said.

A five-judge constitution bench headed by Chief Justice Dipak Misra said that under Article 163, the governor has to act on the aid and advice of the council of minister except in the case where he has to his discretion.

The court is hearing a batch of pleas on who enjoys supremacy in governing the national capital, referred to in Article 239AA of the Constitution.

“The language of Article 163 is similar to Article 239AA sub clause 4 but the only difference is that the Legislative Assembly cannot make laws with respect to entries 1, 2 and 18 in which the LG can his discreation. Thus, the LG has more power than a governor of state,” a bench also comprising justices A K Sikri, A M Khanwilkar, D Y Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan said.

It said land, police and public orders fall in the domain of the Centre and the Assembly cannot make laws with regard to these subject.

Senior advocate Rajeev Dhawan, appearing for the government, said that Article 239AA and the GNCTD Act of 1991, made it clear that the LG is just a delegatee of the President and can only act on his own in case of an urgency.

“The LG cannot run Delhi. He has no role to run the affairs of Delhi. That role is assigned to the council of ministers headed by the chief minister. Nowhere in the Constitution such power has been given to the LG,” he said.

Dhawan questioned as how can the LG say that this officer will stay in a particular department or the officer needs to be transferred to another department.

does not have its own public service commission though it has power to establish one but still it has not done so. The officers posted in Delhi are from all-India cadres of the IAS, IPS and IRS and they listen to the directions of the LG,” Dhawan said.

He said that the LG can interfere in the affairs of only in two cases — if the state government crosses its powers or if Delhi is under some kind of a threat.

The AAP government said that the aid and advice of the council of ministers has some meaning and it is not limited since it is from the elected representatives of the people.

Dhawan said that land, public order and police are with the central government but it cannot be stated that the government has no say.

He cited the violence at Ramlila Maidan that took place during a protest led by yoga guru Ramdev against black money in 2011 and said in those cases when there is threat, chaos and law and order problem, the LG can step in.

To this, the bench said that there cannot be any disagreement over the subjects like land, police or public orders which fall within the domain of the Centre and not the Assembly.

It said that allocation of the business rules does not confer absolute power to the government and they have to work through the provisos.

The apex court had yesterday said the Constitution provided restrictions on the legislative powers of the Union Territory of Delhi.

The AAP government had told the court that Parliament’s power to override legislative authority of the states was an “emergency” power.

The apex court had said that with regard to Delhi’s legislative powers, the state and concurrent lists have been merged into one where both the state and Union have legislative powers.

Earlier, the apex court had raised a question whether the constitutional scheme on division of executive powers between the Centre and the states can be made applicable to Delhi.

The court is hearing a batch of appeals filed by the AAP government challenging the High Court verdict holding that the LG was the administrative head of the national capital.

0 views

Sirf News needs to recruit journalists in large numbers to increase the volume of its reports and articles to at least 100 a day, which will make us mainstream, which is necessary to challenge the anti-India discourse by established media houses. Besides there are monthly liabilities like the subscription fees of news agencies, the cost of a dedicated server, office maintenance, marketing expenses, etc. Donation is our only source of income. Please serve the cause of the nation by donating generously.

Support pro-India journalism by donating

via UPI to surajit.dasgupta@icici or

via PayTM to 9650444033@paytm

via Phone Pe to 9650444033@ibl

via Google Pay to dasgupta.surajit@okicici

Preparations enhanced at Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Int'l Airport, Mumbai with detection of first #Omicron case in the state - 4th in the country.

Thermal Screening areas, registration counters for RT-PCR tests, swab collection booths set up for the pax from 'at-risk' nations

4

I am from a generation where the OATS eaters made us wait decades for a 2-wheeler. Pandemic & Climate Change delays I can understand. But even as a senior citizen, an @OlaElectric scooter I shall ride

With pride

@bhash - more vigor to your team

https://www.wisdomlib.org/definition/ojas

Bhavish Aggarwal@bhash

Scooters are getting ready 🙂 Production ramped up and all geared to begin deliveries from 15th Dec. Thank you for your patience! 3

भारत की आज़ादी के 75 साल !
देश-विदेश में मनाया जा रहा है आज़ादी का #AmritMahotsav
इन रंगारंग कार्यक्रमों की झलकियां ‘आज़ादी का अमृत महोत्सव’ #SansadTV पर
#Nagaland #Konark #Katni
@MinOfCultureGoI @AmritMahotsav

‘Others earning lakhs using my song but my hands are empty’: Peanut seller whose ‘Kacha Badam’ song went viral files police complaint

https://www.opindia.com/2021/12/peanut-seller-whose-kacha-badam-song-went-viral-files-police-complaint/

Read further:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

- Advertisment -

Now

Columns

[prisna-google-website-translator]
%d bloggers like this: