10 C
New Delhi
Sunday 15 December 2019
India INC withdraws 'letter of 154 MLAs' support' from court

INC withdraws ‘letter of 154 MLAs’ support’ from court

Devendra Fadnavis was given time until 7 December, the advocate of BJP said, while that of INC made a claim only to retract it in the court

When the Supreme Court on Monday told Abhishek Manu Singhvi it would have to question the 154 MLAs he claimed were supporting an NCP-INC-Shiv Sena government, the advocate of the INC promptly withdrew the ‘letter of support’ that he had already submitted in the court. On its part, the apex court did not appear to be making much of the petition filed by the INC (and supported by the Shiv Sena) that had demanded a floor test in the Assembly as soon as possible.

The court will pronounce its verdict in the case on Tuesday.


BJP vs INC debate: Singhvi concedes a point

On Monday, there was a heated debate in the court where the lawyers of the BJP, as well as the NCP, urged not to hurry about the floor test. However, the debate revealed that Governor BS Koshyari had given BJP’s Devendra Fadnavis 14 days to prove his majority in the House.

Mukul Rohatgi, appearing for Devendra Fadnavis, appealed to the court that the Assembly’s well laid down procedure ought to be followed for the floor test. He demanded that first the pro-tem speaker should be elected; then the MLAs must take the oath of office and secrecy; then there should be the election of for the speaker, followed by the governor’s address and finally the floor test.

Rohatgi told the court that 14 days were given by the governor to Fadnavis to prove he enjoyed the support of the majority in the Assembly. Till now, it was believed that the deadline was 30 November.

Fadnavis took the oath in the morning of 23 November; the count of 14 days begins from that day. Accordingly, Fadnavis has until 7 December to prove he has the support of the majority.

The advocates of the INC, NCP and Shiv Sena were expected not to agree with the proposition. Abhishek Manu Singhvi said that in many such cases, the Supreme Court had asked the party called to form the government by the governor to prove its majority in 24 hours or 48 hours. In this case, too, there should be no exception. Singhvi said, “Everything will be proved in the floor test.”

Singhvi argued that if both sides were ready for the floor test, there was no reason for a delay. He submitted letters of support of 154 MLAs to the court, but the court was not impressed.

The apex court said that in such a situation, it would have to question these MLAs as well. This made Singhvi withdraw the letter.


The INC and NCP have held throughout that the court should order an immediate appointment of the pro-tem speaker. The rest of the order in which things should happen, according to them, is the same as that stated by Rohatgi: then the MLAs could take the oath and finally the floor test can be conducted.

Solicitor-general’s arguments

Earlier, as scheduled, solicitor-general Tushar Mehta came to the court at 10:30 AM and began his presentation as the Supreme Court had demanded of the Centre (as well as the State of Maharashtra).

Mehta handed over the letters of Maharashtra Governor Koshyari and Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis to the Supreme Court. He asked if the governor’s decision could be challenged in any petition under Article 32. The governor waited till 9 November, said the S-G, and asked the Shiv Sena on the 10th whether it could form the government. It refused, Mehta said. On 11 November, the NCP refused, too, the S-G recalled. Subsequently, President’s rule was imposed, he explained.

The letter Ajit Pawar had given to the governor had signatures of 54 MLAs. Now the deputy chief minister of Maharashtra, Pawar Jr had described himself as the leader of the NCP Legislature Party in the letter. The governor did not need to examine the letter he had received, Mehta argued. He decided to call Devendra Fadnavis for government formation, the S-G- explained, based on the documents laid before him.

“Of course, the floor test is the best, but no party can say that the floor test should be held within 24 hours. Give us two or three days’ time. Allow filing the answer. The governor of Maharashtra had the privilege of inviting the largest party on 23 November,” Mehta said

“Assembly procedures like the election of a pro-tem speaker cannot be interfered with,” Mehta said. The Supreme Court cannot ask the governor of Maharashtra to conduct a floor test within 24 hours, he added, insisting that “the floor test cannot be done tomorrow”.

“The governor has given 14 days. The proper time should be seven days,” Mehta added.

The Supreme Court will now pronounce its verdict in the case on Tuesday.

In the latest development, the BJP claims they have the support of more than 160 MLAs.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi

Leave a Reply


Justice That Is Instant Is Travesty

But neither the state nor society can wash their hands off this social craving for settling scores in the name of doing justice to the victim

Karnataka Voters Punished INC, JDS Leaders

Even the BJP was not confident of the result even as their leaders kept saying for public consumption they were winning all the 15 seats

The United States Of The World

The United States, stereotyped as the land of plenty and plentiful guns, is still a destination of choice for people from across the world

प्याज़ के आँसू न रोएँ — महंगाई से किसान, उपभोक्ता दोनों को फ़ायदा

जिस अल्प मुद्रास्फीति की वजह से वे सरकार से बहुत खुश थे, उसी 1.38 प्रतिशत की खाद्यान्न मुद्रास्फीति के कारण किसानों को अपने पैदावार के लिए समुचित मूल्य नहीं मिल रहे थे

CAB Can Correct Wrongs Of NRC

… if the government can fix the inept bureaucracy and explain what happens to those marked as aliens, as the neighbours are not taking them back
- Advertisement -


Gurdwara discards 30 kg of cooked dal, realising it was ‘plastic’

The historic Gurudwara Bangla Sahib realised again the next day that the lentils were fake but got alerted before the dal was cooked

Prashant Kishor to campaign for AAP in Delhi election

Prashant Kishor has been successful as an election strategist in most campaigns: BJP at Centre 2014, JDU in Bihar 2015, INC in Punjab 2017

Service sector picks pace; trade deficit reduces

Service exports stood at $ 17.70 billion in October, registering a growth of 5.25%; trade deficit declined from $ 17.58 billion in 2018 to $ 12.12 billion

Sabarimala verdict review: SC snubs Fathima, Bindu

Ignoring the court decision to refer the Sabarimala review pleas to a 7-judge bench, the petitioners tried to get an order to enter the shrine immediately

Andhra Cabinet okays Disha Bill that dictates judiciary

While ordering the prosecution to complete its work in 14 days is permissible, Andhra Pradesh cannot set a time limit for the judiciary

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: