Fear-Mongering In The Times Of CAA

Dire scenarios have popped up in the news media or in the statements of church leaders, Western politicians, academics, and activists in the past whenever the BJP has led the Government of India

Columnist

News

India got the best messages and deals possible from Trump

While the US president struck the right note in the beginning by mentioning Islamic terrorism, he did not cry foul over levies India puts on imports from America

Yogi govt penalises rioters, does not compensate them

Answering Samajwadi Party MLA Rakesh Pratap Singh, Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath said that the government had no provision of paying rioters

Rampur court jails Azam Khan, wife, son to for 3 days

The Rampur court was hearing two cases against Azam Khan's son Abdullah, accused of furnishing fake birth certificates forged by his parents

Doval takes stock of riot-ravaged north-east Delhi

Doval had visited Seelampur in the night too, where he discussed the prevailing situation with the commissioner and other high-ranking cops

Ankit Sharma after Ratan Lal: Anti-CAA killers’ hit list now includes cops

Rioters protesting against CAA have injured two IPS officers and 56 other policemen and killed IB constable Ankit Sharma after HC Ratan Lal

Shoot-at-sight order, curfew in N-E Delhi; riot toll 13

The SP of Delhi Police in the Yamuna Vihar area issued the shoot-at-sight order; Maujpur, Jafrabad, Chand Bagh and Karawal Nagar are under curfew

Journalists attacked by anti-CAA protesters: Riot toll 9

Anti-CAA rioters brutally assaulted journalists of JK 24x7 and NDTV while Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia said the attackers were 'monsters' not belonging to Delhi

Ratan Lal died of bullet injury: Post-mortem report

Ratan Lal from Rajasthan had joined Delhi Police as a constable in 1998; he was living in Amrit Vihar with his wife and three children

Riots to protest against CAA consume 7 lives: 10 updates

Shahrukh, who had opened fire at cops on 24 February in N-E Delhi, has been arrested, even as Shah and Kejriwal sought ways to end the riots

BJP recognises Marandi, makes him legislative party head

'BJP MLAs will work under his leadership with team spirit,' party president JP Nadda-appointed central observer Muralidhar Rao said

Bhajanpura of Delhi after Maujpur as Shaheen Bagh subsides

Muslim mobs set the Bhajanpura petrol pump, 10 houses and many vehicles on fire after killing a cop in Maujpur to protest against the CAA

Trump flags ‘radical Islam’ as joint Indian-American concern

India and the US are committed to fighting terrorists. My government is working with Pakistan to crack down on terror groups: President Trump

Maujpur Metro station closed; ‘certain community’ kills constable

The trouble began when some CAA supporters arrived at Maujpur and questioned the protesters as to what right they had to inconvenience others

Kapil Mishra sensation, Swara Bhasker condescension: Sunday on Twitter

While Kapil Mishra trended on Twitter for issuing an ultimatum to Delhi Police to clear the road through Jafrabad, Swara Bhasker made a joke of herself on TV

Vinay Sharma claims to have swallowed a pin in another bid to escape gallows

Earlier, Vinay Sharma had banged his head on the cell wall and then tried to fracture his arms by entangling them around the iron grills

Roadshow to receive Trump 22 km long

The Ahmedabad civic body is not leaving any stone unturned to make the roadshow a memorable experience for citizens and the dignitaries

Habibullah gives clean chit to Shaheen Bagh activists, slams Delhi Police

Appointed mediator to end the Shaheen Bagh deadlock, the former National Minorities Commission chairman and CIC comes back to the Supreme Court unsuccessful

Judge head over heels in praise of PM Modi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is a versatile genius who thinks globally and acts locally, Justice Arun Mishra, the third-most senior Supreme Court judge said

Shaheen Bagh activists lift and soon resume blockade

Activists at Shaheen Bagh placed a set of seven demands before interlocutor Sadhana Ramachandran, none of which she was empowered to concede

BJP to Kejriwal: Govt of India doesn’t choose Trumps’ guests

BJP reacts to AAP's criticism that the names of Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal and his deputy Manish Sisodia were dropped from a school event
- Advertisement -

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get our latest reports and articles via email

Ramesh Rao
Ramesh Raohttps://www.sirfnews.com/
Professor of communication studies at Columbus State University, Columbus, GA; opinions expressed here are personal
- Advertisement -

No one lived in this country with so much fear before,” asserted a friend while dealing with India’s newly amended citizenship law (referred to popularly as the CAA) with such ferocious conviction that I wondered if the India I had visited just a few weeks ago was some kind of a Gulag where Christians and Muslims were being transported in trains to spend their lives in the Rajasthan desert, listening to RSS leaders talking about Lord Rāma and getting them lined up for “ghar wāpsi” rituals, or whether India had become a hall of mirrors where WhatsApp messages constituted reality. I wondered if it mattered at all that Indians lived their lives with any modicum of honesty or what really mattered was the willingness of activists, ideologues, and politicians to manipulate reality and how deftly they constructed simulacra — anything that would go viral on Twitter or be incorporated into a report in the local newspaper whose editors were eager to grind their particular political axes or a hit-piece in The New York Times.

How the anti-CAA riots were manufactured and how they morphed into general mayhem, ‘peace marches’, and national ‘bandhs’, which then got deftly mixed into local issues, JNU fee agitation, or whatever was politically convenient need to be told one day by historians who can sift through the deluge of political chaff from the little grains of reality and tell readers how fear was stoked by whom, for what reason, and through what venues.

But the manufacturing of imagined scenarios, as they have done in the case of CAA, is neither new nor unique to the present-day Indian situation: these dire scenarios have popped up in the news media or in the statements of church leaders, Western politicians, academics, and activists in the past, and especially when the BJP was set to win an election. Thus, back in 1998, editors of left-leaning magazines and newspapers, like N Ram of The Hindu/Frontline, collaborated with activists and academics both in India and in the US to start a “watch group” called “BJP Watch” when the BJP formed the NDA coalition government. They offered a provocative selection of commentaries and reports that claimed that with the BJP in power the lives of minorities would be at risk, that they would be literally pushed into the Arabian Sea, and that riots would be manufactured to make India a Hindu nation.

The creation of this “watch group” was described benignly by an India Today report as “peculiar” and “adventurous,” and that the group included “eminent scholars”. It said that Ram had warned that “Given the RSS’ semi-fascist origins, we are suspicious about the BJP’s attitude towards civil society and democracy… The BJP threatens the institutions of civil society”. That the editors of the inaptly named The Hindu to continue with their old mischief, stoking fear, evoking a variety of political, civilisational, and cultural horror has been noted here and here but now they are not the only ones to manufacture this nonsense. We can scroll through the print and wire versions (pun intended) of the “mainstream” media whose army of reporters and commentators skillfully drum up and present biased reports and analyses which then feeds into the “never has there been so much fear” worldview of those viscerally opposed to the BJP.

The USCIRF had, in a statement in early December 2019, alleged that the CAA, which was yet to become law, specifically excluded Muslims from it and thus made religion a legal criterion, which was factually incorrect

If this news dynamic was confined only within the Indian media space, there would be less consequence. Between 1998 and now, however, we have seen that a variety of foreign forces, international media, and Indian groups based in the West also contributing to and ratcheting up the pressure on the BJP governments. Academics quickly line up to sign petitions that condemn the BJP leadership or any law they make, and they have done so in the case of the CAA. American government agencies and committees, like the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) are quick to add fuel to the fire, lecture to Indian leaders, and intrude into the affairs of the nation.

That the USCIRF, which lectured Indian government on CAA, is commandeered by rightwing Christian commissioners has been noted here, and having interacted with both the commissioners and the USCIRF staff, this author knows firsthand how “religious freedom” is used as a convenient handle for encouraging Christian proselytism around the world. Concerns that we expressed about predatory proselytism were brushed aside not only by the USCIRF commissioners but also by staff at the US State Department, which also produces annual reports on “religious freedom” around the world.

Those that the USCIRF and the State Department rely on to provide grist for their mill include Indian-American groups like the Federation of Indian American Christian Organizations (FIACONA), whose website is full of anti-Hindu drivel, and the Indian American Muslim Council (IAMC) which is even more adept in circulating, through their weekly emails and newsletters and their website posts, the most virulent anti-Hindu propaganda (available plentifully through the Indian media), strategically masked as “anti-Hindutva” opinions and reports.

That these Christian and Muslim organisations, otherwise at loggerheads around the world, collaborate to demonise Hindus and Hindu political activism goes to show how the two supremacist and monopolist religious groups work in tandem in their bid to eventually make the world Christian or Muslim. It is not surprising therefore that this anti-Hindu propaganda/activism gets picked up by international Christian agencies and media, who then use their clout in the halls of power to have their bidding done, and whose messages then get recirculated in Indian Christian media and churches. It is an echo chamber.

What was dumbfounding, on my recent visit to India, was to watch the dozen or so Christian channels on TV — with swarthy pastors blathering 24×7 in Kannada, Telugu, Tamil, Hindi… about how Lord Jesus Christ was going to save Hindus and bring justice, peace, and goodness to the land of Bharat that is India. Alas, none of India’s sociologists, cultural warriors, and activists bothers to do careful content analyses of the propaganda on these channels and how they construct scenarios of threat and martyrdom among the most ignorant viewers of these channels. The writers who get featured in The Economic and Political Weekly, wear well-manufactured blinkers so that they can avoid looking at and listening to the drivel.

The views of the Indian left and its clever band of “minority” collaborators thus have seeped deep into certain sections of Indian society, including students in elite colleges and universities — with the deracinated and anglicised Hindu turning out to be the most vociferous of the BJP’s opponents. They will read The New York Times and the Economist, pay through their nose for subscribing to these foreign news media, watch CNN and Al Jazeera, and believe that these venues offer “real” news.

But the tide has begun to turn, with social media enabling ordinary viewers and readers to doubt and challenge the false and the fake narratives, and for a nascent and small group of English language news portals and magazines to offer alternative narratives. Unless there is balance in news reports and unless space is offered for a variety of opinions, fearmongering as in the case of CAA will continue.

Some dismiss these new venues as “right-wing media”, fearful what they read there may challenge their view of the world, but having been involved in writing for some of these newspapers and magazines over the past twenty-five years, one notices that enough force has been gathered to begin to poke holes in the left/’progressive’ fortress. India just needs to keep at it.

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Science & Technology

परी महल — कश्मीर का आध्यात्मिक स्थल या भूतों का निवास?

परी महल के बारे में एक लोकप्रिय कथा यह है कि कोई जादूगर राजकुमारियों का अपहरण कर उन्हें यहाँ बंदी बना कर रखता था

Lancet lends credence to Sen Cotton’s allegation China is lying

The Lancet does note that the systems in China have improved greatly since the 2003 SARS attack, but that makes it all the more stunning why the government of that country suppressed facts from its own citizens and the world for a long time
- Advertisement -

Appeal

Dear Sirf News subscriber,

वंदेमातरम्!

We started this media venture with a resolve to offer our readers, listeners and viewers content they were not getting from mainstream media: Truth not coloured by political correctness. We waited for a while as some alternatives arrived. But with dismay, we observed that the wannabe substitutes were merely reacting to the news supplied by conventional journalists; they did not have reporters of their own. As a result, the agenda kept being set by the old guard.

To know first hand what is happening in different parts of the country and the world, we need to have reporters posted in all those locations: at least one in every state of India and 15-20 correspondents to cover the Union ministries, national political parties and institutions; at least one in the capital of every important country. Since mass communication schools teach journalism in a certain way that maintains the status quo, we need to spend on fresh training of our recruits, too.

Other costs involve the salaries of desk staff (from sub-editors up to the chief editor), server fee, agencies' charges and office maintenance.

To protect our independence, we do not seek fund from government or the corporate sector. The choice, therefore, is only you. Please help us stay in the business of serving you unadulterated information and well-informed opinions.

Please click on the button "Support Sirf News" below and donate an amount you can afford. Your contribution will be acknowledged and sincerely appreciated.

जय हिन्द!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More Articles Like This

- Advertisement -

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: