14.9 C
New Delhi
Sunday 15 December 2019
Economy EAC-PM rubbishes Arvind Subramanian’s claims on GDP

EAC-PM rubbishes Arvind Subramanian’s claims on GDP

EAC-PM about Arvind Subramanian's hypothesis: Any attempt to sensationalise what should be a proper academic debate is not desirable

New Delhi: The Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) has rubbished former chief economic adviser (CEA) Arvind Subramanian‘s claim of India’s ‘inflated’ GDP figures. The council said Subramanian should have raised the issue while he was working as the CEA. Of course, by his own admission, he has taken time to understand India’s growth numbers and is still unsure of his own figures.

“Any attempt to sensationalise what should be a proper academic debate is not desirable from the point of view of preserving the independence and quality of India’s statistical systems, all of which the former CEA is familiar with,” the EAC-PM said.

Recently, a study “Mis-estimation of the Magnitudes, Mechanisms, and Implications about India’s GDP”, published at the Harvard University. In the article, former CEA Arvind Subramanian had stated that the country’s growth had been overestimated by around 2.5% points between 2011-12 and 2016-17.

But the official estimates have pegged the average annual growth at around 7% during this period. Therefore, the actual GDP growth is likely to have been lower, at around 4.5%, Subramanian wrote.

The article led to a debate on the actual growth numbers nationwide and also internationally, as the state of the Indian economy is today important to the world. The response from the EAC-PM was awaited since then.

Responding to Subramanian’s claim, the EAC-PM said, “We do not use tax indicators because of the major changes in direct and indirect taxes in the post-2011 period which render the tax-to-GDP relationship different and unstable, and hence make the indicators unreliable proxies for GDP growth.”

“The author’s logic of not using tax data appears to be a convenient argument meant to avoid inconvenient conclusions based on hard facts,” the EAC-PM said. The contributors of the paper were economists Bibek Debroy, Rathin Roy, Surjit Bhalla, Charan Singh and Arvind Virmani.

The government stated that the GDP estimates are based on “accepted procedures, methodologies, and available data and objectively measure the contribution of various sectors in the economy”. The methodology of a compilation of macroaggregates has been discussed in detail by a committee comprising experts from academia, National Statistical Commission, Indian Statistical Institute, Reserve Bank of India (RBI), Ministries of Finance, Corporate Affairs, Agriculture, NITI Aayog and select State governments.

The EAC-PM Wednesday said that the base year of India’s income calculations switched to 2011-12, based on recommendations of several committees and it was wrong to suggest that the views of experts had not been taken into account.

The EAC-PM Council said further that the proxy indicators used by Subramanian could be questioned. They said his analysis did not allow GDP increases on the basis of productivity gains. The council added that it would examine in further detail the estimates made in Subramanian’s paper and come out with a point-by-point rebuttal in due course.

In the meantime, NITI issued a press release that read: “The note provides detailed evidence that indicates that Dr Subramanian has cherry-picked a few indicators and performed a rather unconvincing regression analysis to prove his hypothesis that India’s GDP was over-estimated post-2011-12.”

“The new methodology that uses 2011-12 as the base year includes two major improvements, a) Incorporation of MCA21 database, and b) Incorporation of the Recommendations of System of National Accounts (SNA), 2008. This change was in line with other countries that have changed their methodologies in line with SNA 2008 and revised their respective GDP figures. On an average, real GDP estimates saw an increase of 0.7% among OECD countries,” the release read.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi

Leave a Reply


Justice That Is Instant Is Travesty

But neither the state nor society can wash their hands off this social craving for settling scores in the name of doing justice to the victim

Karnataka Voters Punished INC, JDS Leaders

Even the BJP was not confident of the result even as their leaders kept saying for public consumption they were winning all the 15 seats

The United States Of The World

The United States, stereotyped as the land of plenty and plentiful guns, is still a destination of choice for people from across the world

प्याज़ के आँसू न रोएँ — महंगाई से किसान, उपभोक्ता दोनों को फ़ायदा

जिस अल्प मुद्रास्फीति की वजह से वे सरकार से बहुत खुश थे, उसी 1.38 प्रतिशत की खाद्यान्न मुद्रास्फीति के कारण किसानों को अपने पैदावार के लिए समुचित मूल्य नहीं मिल रहे थे

CAB Can Correct Wrongs Of NRC

… if the government can fix the inept bureaucracy and explain what happens to those marked as aliens, as the neighbours are not taking them back
- Advertisement -


NEFT transaction 24×7 beginning 16 December

NEFT is a method of online transaction, in which you can transfer to another bank account up to Rs 2 lakh online at a time

Decision to amend Citizenship Act 1,000% honest: PM Modi

'We have brought this law to give citizenship to minorities of Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh who have endured a lot of persecution'

Nirbhaya case convicts: Why 2 will take longer to die

Further, a source in the jail said while four rapists and killers of Nirbhaya are supposed to hang on one day, they have ordered 10 ropes

India to begin ODI series as favourites against West Indies

Shimron Hetmyer and Nicholas Pooran have shown their ability in T20; if the WI must challenge India, they will have to do the same in ODIs

‘Rahul Savarkar’ remark riles INC ally Shiv Sena

More newsworthy than the BJP's response that Rahul cannot even dream of being a Savarkar is the protest by Shiv Sena, INC's ally in Maharashtra

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: