23 C
New Delhi
Friday 6 December 2019
India Discrepancies in Irani's affidavits

Discrepancies in Irani’s affidavits

After targeting Indian National Congress (INC) leaders Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi over their apparently dubious education qualifications, it is now the Bharatiya Janata Party’s turn to brave counterattack on account of two different educational details filed by the Human Resource Development Minister Smriti Zubin Irani. In 2004 – when she contested from Chandni Chowk constituency in Delhi – Irani had declared her educational qualification as “BA 1996 Delhi University (School of Correspondence)”. But in the affidavit filed by her for the recently concluded election in Amethi in Uttar Pradesh, she deposed that she had done “Bachelor of Commerce Part-1, School of Open Learning (Correspondence), University of Delhi-1994”.

As per the School of Open Learning, Part-1 is the first year of the three-year programme. Her affidavit while filing the nomination for the Rajya Sabha election in 2011 also cites BCom Part-I, School of Correspondence, University of Delhi, 1994.

Controversy over Irani’s qualifications as well as no evidence of flair for the subject of education in her past erupted the day before yesterday when the media was speculating she would be given the HRD Ministry. The first set of people to raise the issue of her under-qualification was, ironically, online supporters of the BJP. The persons who drew maximum attention towards themselves yesterday for the question was a hardcore campaigner for Narendra Modi’s prime ministership, Madhu Kishwar, followed by former Union Minister Ajay Maken.

Kishwar posted on Twitter: “Irani claims to be BCom part 1 frm (sic) correspondence school. No such degree exists. Means just took admission and left. Misrepresentn (sic) in affidavit.” Another of her posts said, “Congress & Left have nurtured intellectuals, academics for decades. BJP neglected this arena. @narendramodi better put worthy person in HRD”. Wishing to be seen as an issue-based, rather than blind, supporter of the Modi Government, the critic had written: “Now onwards NaMo will be judged by performance as PM. Old track record as CM very important but doesn’t mean blind support taken for granted (sic).”

Maken’s observation was ironical because he once faced barbs from party colleague and senior Mani Shankar Aiyar who had snobbishly dismissed a letter from him, saying the language used in it couldn’t possibly be from someone who had been a student of Delhi’s Hansraj College. “What a Cabinet of Modi? HRD Minister (Looking after Education) Smriti Irani is not even a graduate! Look at her affidavit at ECI site pg 11 (sic)!” Mr Maken tweeted, immediately inviting sharp reactions.

Latching onto the issue of Irani’s qualifications today, the INC said she was guilty of a “mis-statement, distortion and a criminal offence”, which have electoral consequences. “We don’t know which is correct–2004 or 2014? Both can’t be true,” party Spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi told reporters.

Reacting to the criticism, Minister for Water Resources and Ganga Rejuvenation Uma Bharti has shot back, “I want to ask Madam Sonia Gandhi, what is her qualification?”

Interestingly, since yesterday, a lot of examples of formally uneducated but politically successful personalities have been given in defence of Irani, but not one name in the list is of an education minister. This ministry has conventionally gone to a legislator of the ruling party who has some university degrees to his or her credit, whether at the Centre or in a State. Perhaps a reason that BJP supporters were the first to raise the issue online is that, as prime ministerial candidate of the party, Modi, through his electoral speeches, had raised hopes of a meritocratic and/or technocratic council of ministers that the middle class youth by and large believed could extricate the country out of the poor shape the last government had left it in. One aspect of governance that Modi had indicated needed a big boost was human resource.

सिर्फ़ News chief editor Surajit Dasgupta argued against Irani’s appointment as the HRD minister but supported the idea of her inclusion in a ministry commensurate with her track record in public life yesterday in the article, “Strange choice for HRD,” published in this website.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi
Surajit Dasgupta
Surajit Dasgupta
The founder of सिर्फ़ News has been a science correspondent in The Statesman, senior editor in The Pioneer, special correspondent in Money Life and columnist in various newspapers and magazines, writing in English as well as Hindi. He was the national affairs editor of Swarajya, 2014-16. He worked with Hindusthan Samachar in 2017. He was the first chief editor of Sirf News and is now back at the helm after a stint as the desk head of MyNation of the Asianet group. He is a mathematician by training with interests in academic pursuits of science, linguistics and history. He advocates individual liberty and a free market in a manner that is politically feasible. His hobbies include Hindi film music and classical poetry in Bengali, English, French, Hindi and Urdu.

Leave a Reply


Trump Drives Democrats And Media Crazy

America can never be the same again, even after Trump leaves the White House,” say many, and you can read that anywhere

Balasaheb Thackeray’s Legacy Up For Grabs

The Uddhav Thackeray-led Shiv Sena has failed to live up to the ideals of Balasaheb, leaving a void that the BJP alone can fill

How BJP Pulled Off Maha Coup With Nobody Watching

As Devendra Fadnavis desisted from contradicting Uddhav Thackeray everyday, the media attention moved from the BJP to its noisy rivals

Anil Ambani: From Status Of Tycoon To Insolvency

Study the career of Anil Ambani, and you will get a classic case of decisions you ought not take as a businessman and time you better utilise

तवलीन सिंह, यह कैसा स्वाभिमान?

‘जिस मोदी सरकार का पांच साल सपोर्ट किया उसी ने मेरे बेटे को देश निकाला दे दिया,’ तवलीन सिंह ने लिखा। क्या आपने किसी क़ीमत के बदले समर्थन किया?
- Advertisement -


Nirav declared 2nd fugitive economic offender

Nirav Modi, fighting his extradition case in England, was further remanded, unable to convince the court he wouldn't intimidate witnesses

RBI policy rates intact; SBI disapproves status quo

The 6-member MPC headed by the RBI governor unanimously decided to maintain the repo rate at 5.15% and the reverse repo rate at 4.90%

Parliament canteen to stop offering subsidised food

The Narendra Modi government had been reducing the subsidy for food at the Parliament canteen gradually since 2016; it will now be eliminated

Burnt body found again: Bengal after Telangana, Bihar, UP

Bengal Police confirmed that the woman was burnt and killed on 4 December in Malda while they could confirm rape after the autopsy report

Citizenship, Dabholkar, Bhima-Koregaon divide Maha govt

The INC not only disagrees with the Shiv Sena on the Citizenship Amendment Bill but also questions the NCP for the Bhima-Koregaon riots

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this:
Skip to toolbar