Sunday 4 December 2022
- Advertisement -
PoliticsWorldBritish Muslims' citizenship downgraded, says leftist think-tank, while law mentions no religion

British Muslims’ citizenship downgraded, says leftist think-tank, while law mentions no religion

The status of British Muslims has reduced, making them "second-class" citizens, a new report by a leftist think-tank says rather baselessly. The Institute of Race Relations (IRR) released the report on 11 September, titled, "Citizenship: From Right to Privilege," reacting to the recent expansion of the contentious powers in the Nationality and Borders Act of the UK that permit citizenship to be revoked from a person without notice.

Clause 9, the new law, was added to the bill in April, allowing British nationals to be stripped of their citizenship without notice. The clause implies a British citizen who is abroad and is deprived of citizenship might not even know about it. That is until "they try to come home and are refused boarding or they need help from the British Embassy because their passport, money etc have been lost or stolen", the report said. Clearly, there is no mention of in the clause.

Those potentially affected by the clause could be any British citizen — whether born British, registered or naturalised — who has another citizenship, any naturalised British citizen with access to another citizenship. According to the New Statesman, up to six million citizens have or have access to a second citizenship.

Previously, British nationals whose citizenship was revoked were required to be notified by letter. 

Those stripped of citizenship have a right to challenge the decision through an appeals process, and critics say that removing the need to notify somebody prevents them from exercising that right.

Government officials say the change would affect only a small handful of people. 

The clause "brought home to a wider public how precarious and fragile British citizenship is for Black and Muslim citizens", the report said.

"The message sent by the legislation on deprivation of citizenship since 2002 and its implementation largely against British Muslims of South Asian heritage is that, despite their passports, these people are not and can never be 'true' citizens, in the same way that 'natives' are," Frances Webber, the vice-chair of the IRR and the report's author said.

"While a 'native' British citizen, who has access to no other citizenship, can commit the most heinous crimes without jeopardising his right to remain British, none of the estimated six million British citizens with access to another citizenship can feel confident in the perpetual of their citizenship," the author says without explaining how people he refers to as 'natives' cannot be denied citizenship using Clause 9.

Before 2003, no removal of citizenship had been authorised by the British government for 30 years, the report points out, but there have been at least 217 removals of citizenship since then, with 104 removals in 2017.

The Nationality and Borders Bill came under harsh condemnation, before becoming law, from human rights organisations, the legal community, and the UK parliament's own Joint Committee on Human Rights.

The British government's use of citizenship-stripping powers was likely discriminatory and illegal because of its disproportionate impact on Muslim and immigrant populations, according to experts, who also criticised the measure earlier this year.

Click/tap on a tag for more on the subject


Of late

More like this