19 C
New Delhi
Wednesday 20 November 2019
India Bose family decries Gumnaami; Mission Netaji punches holes in...

Bose family decries Gumnaami; Mission Netaji punches holes in their theory

While the kin of Subhas Chandra Bose rubbish the Gumnami angle, Mission Netaji explains why the family finds it inconvenient


- Advertisment -

Subscribe to our newsletter

You will get all our latest news and articles via email when you subscribe

The email despatches will be non-commercial in nature
Disputes, if any, subject to jurisdiction in New Delhi

Kolkata: Filmmaker Srijit Mukherji’s next outing ‘Gumnaami’, based on theories surrounding Netaji’s disappearance, has stirred up a hornet’s nest, with the Bose family claiming that “a defamatory campaign was being made to malign the image of the legendary leader”.

In a counter-argument, the director, however, said that the film, cleared by the CBFC on Wednesday, sought to project all the three theories surrounding the “disappearance” of Netaji in a balanced manner. The film did not portray Gumnaami baba, a monk spotted in Faizabad in the 1970s, as Netaji, he said.

A statement signed by 33 members of the Bose family, contended that “a long-running and sinister campaign is being organised… which features a penniless recluse known as Gumnami Baba, who left behind trunkloads of Netaji-related fake collectables”. It said further that “a misleading and defamatory campaign was being made to malign the image and legacy of the legendary leader”.

Among the signatories were Netaji’s daughter Anita Pfaff, niece Chitra Ghosh, grandnephew and BJP leader Chandra Bose, nephew Dwarkanath Bose and niece Krishna Bose.

Noting that Justice Mukherjee Commission of Inquiry of 2005 provided conclusive proof through DNA testing to establish there was no match between Netaji and this Gumnami Baba, the letter demanded “an end to the campaign”. Krishna Bose, who is also the director of Netaji Research Bureau, said, “Everyone has the right to make a film for a commercial reason but none has the right to insult the great patriot.”

Editor’s note

Justice (retd) Manoj Mukherjee was not “conclusive” in his findings. Based on the lack of categorical forensic substantiation, Mukherjee had stopped probing the Gumnami angle further.

Filmmaker Mukherji, on his part, said the Mukherjee Commission had mentioned Gumnami Baba in its report. “Even if you discount a theory, you have to give references, you have to mention it… We have no intention to insult Netaji, we have shown our respect to him in the film,” the filmmaker said. “It is a democracy, a filmmaker has every right to show all possible theories and talk about the mysteries surrounding the great icon, we are all proud of,” he said.

The national award-winning filmmaker said further, “We have made the film from three standpoints and left it for the audience to decide. The film, once released, will prove that” he said, adding the “Censor Board has given a nod to the film, which goes on to show the Union government has okayed the film’s content”.

Different theories have swirled around Netaji’s disappearance in 1945, with one being that he returned to India and lived under the guise of ‘Gumnami Baba’, a reclusive Sadhu, in Uttar Pradesh’s Faizabad. Some others have claimed that Bose boarded a plane on 18 August 1945 at Taihoku airport in Taiwan which crashed leading to his death.

The third theory suggests that Netaji was captured and murdered in a prison in Russia. A recent tweet by PIB observing 18 August as the freedom fighter’s death anniversary came in the eye of the storm, with Chandra Bose asserting that it was not the right approach as the mystery over the leader’s death was yet to be resolved. Netaji’s daughter has sought Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s intervention for a DNA test of the ashes, believed to be of the leader, kept at Renkoji temple in Japan.

Netaji kin living in denial, says Mission Netaji founding member

In the meantime, Sreejith Panickar of Mission Netaji has challenged the denial by members of the third generation of Subhas Chandra Bose’s extended family. Panickar says that these family members had taken a position in 2013, according to which the air crash theory was bogus, but now they were once again inching close to that theory.

Explaining their clash with the Bose family, co-author of Conundrum Chandrachur Ghose said to Sirf News that the Gumnami story is inconvenient for the Netaji kin, as they would be questioned why Netaji did not look for them once he returned to India.

Another member of Mission Netaji said under the condition of anonymity that Subhas Chandra Bose when around, did not regard his extended family highly. “There was only one elder brother he trusted. The rest, Netaji said, were too close to the Congress to care for him,” The Mission Netaji activist said.


Leave a Reply


Anil Ambani: From Status Of Tycoon To Insolvency

Study the career of Anil Ambani, and you will get a classic case of decisions you ought not take as a businessman and time you better utilise

तवलीन सिंह, यह कैसा स्वाभिमान?

‘जिस मोदी सरकार का पांच साल सपोर्ट किया उसी ने मेरे बेटे को देश निकाला दे दिया,’ तवलीन सिंह ने लिखा। क्या आपने किसी क़ीमत के बदले समर्थन किया?

Rafale: One Embarrassment, One Snub For Opposition

Supreme Court accepts Rahul Gandhi's apology for attributing to it his allegation, rejects the review petition challenging the Rafale verdict

Guru Nanak Jayanti: What First Sikh Guru Taught

While Guru Nanak urged people to 'nām japo, kirat karo, vand chhako', he stood for several values while he also fought various social evils

Muhammed Who Inconvenienced Muslims

Archaeologist KK Muhammed had earlier got on the nerves of the leftist intelligentsia for exposing their nexus with Islamic extremists
- Advertisement -


Kashmir cable operators warned for showing Islamic countries’ channels

While the channels of Pakistan, Turkey and Malaysia that Kashmir cable operators show have anti-India content, others radicalise the youth

Owaisi takes on Banerjee as ‘secular’ lobby splits like 2002

Reacting to West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's flagging of the issue of "minority bigotry", All India...

Rahul Gandhi’s absence exposes funny AI of cameras in LS

When Congress MP K Suresh spoke from the seat designated to Rahul Gandhi, the Lok Sabha LED screen flashed a misrepresentative caption

Bharat Ratna to Savarkar needs no recommendation: Govt

BJP manifesto for Maharashtra had pledged to recommend Bharat Ratna for Savarkar to the Centre if it could form government in the State

JNU students hold Delhi to ransom; police turn ingenious to disperse the mob

Police have rubbished reports that said the cops had unleashed lathi-charge on JNU students and said the men in khaki were just persuasive

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you

For fearless journalism

%d bloggers like this: